A decision to send the paper for review can take longer, but usually within a month (in which case the editors send apologies). In the event of publication, the received date is the date of submission to the journal where the manuscript is published. Internet Explorer). HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. When all the reviewer reports are received, the editors decide to either: If you are invited to revise and resubmit your manuscript, you should follow the instructions provided by the editor in their decision email. I would recommend the rejection of a manuscript based on the following: 1. This should not be a repetition of what you have included in your original submission or cover letter. So, it probably means that the associate editor (AE), who handles the manuscript through the review and publication process, had a look at your manuscript and made a decision on it, most probably for rejection. Here to foster information exchange with the library community. "Editor decision started" means that the editor is actively reading the manuscript. Scan this QR code to download the app now. Incomplete data. What could this mean? Decline publication, typically on grounds of either there being insufficient support for the conclusions or a reassessment of the level of interest or advance in light of the reviewers' comments. Please note, this decision must be made at the time of initial submission and cannot be changed later. Inappropriate methodology for answering your hypothesis or using old methodology that has been surpassed by newer, more . In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles Read Editage Insights in your favorite RSS Reader. For more information,please refer to our FAQ page. Editors will not send resubmitted papers to the reviewers if it seems that the authors have not made a serious attempt to address all the referees criticisms. Nature is reluctant to consult new referees unless there is a particular, relevant area of scientific expertise that was lacking in the referees already used. Did you find it helpful? Editage Insights offers a wealth of free academic research and publishing resources and is a one-stop guide for authors and others involved in scholarly publishing. How do I write an inquiry to the editor about my manuscript's current status? Hence, Nature prefers to stick with the original referees of a particular paper rather than to call in new referees to arbitrate, unless there is some specific way in which the referee can be shown to be technically lacking or biased in judgement. Authors will be contacted immediately after a decision has been made. . The EiC may have seen merits in your paper after all (or a fit, if that was the issue). On the basis of the external reviews and their own reading, the editor makes a decision on the manuscript (accept, revise, reject but encourage resubmission, reject). 4b. Thank the reviewers and editors for their time and comments. Authors are provided the opportunity to opt out of this scheme at the completion of the peer review process, before the paper is accepted. What does a quick change from 'Under consideration' to 'Decision made' back to 'Under consideration' mean for Nature? Authors can request an extension, if needed. In this case, it is important to notify the editors that you are withdrawing your manuscript, and get confirmation that this it has been withdrawn, before you submit it to a different journal. Until then, you may find it worthwhile to go through the following resources about journal statuses: Answered by Irfan Syed Some authors ask the editors to reconsider a rejection decision. All Articles published in Nature go through at least one round of review, usually two or three, sometimes more. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Although Nature's editors regard it as essential that any technical failings noted by referees are addressed, they are not so strictly bound by referees editorial opinions as to whether the work belongs in Nature. Thank you for visiting nature.com. The paper is rejected with no offer to reconsider a resubmitted version. var d=new Date(); yr=d.getFullYear();document.write(yr); Logging into the system with your password. All Rights Reserved. Full disclosure: Editage Insights is a product of Editage, a global provider of world-class scientific communication solutions. The science editor has sole responsibility for the decision to accept or reject a manuscript, and that decision is final. How long should I wait for a response from the journal? Learn how to publish, peer review and collaborate with the online courses from Nature Masterclasses.